Handmade Information

Tucked away on W New Orleans Street in Broken Arrow, Handmade is one of those spots that immediately feels like a hidden gem the moment you walk through the door. The atmosphere is cozy yet modern, with warm lighting and rustic touches that give it a welcoming, relaxed vibe-perfect whether you’re grabbing a quick bite or lingering over a leisurely meal. The menu showcases a thoughtful mix of dishes that clearly emphasizes quality and care, from fresh, locally sourced ingredients to inventive takes on classic favorites. From the moment the plates hit the table, you can tell that presentation and flavor are equally important here, and every item seems prepared with deliberate attention. The sandwiches and artisanal salads stand out for their balance of textures and bold flavors, while the chef-driven specials often highlight seasonal ingredients in exciting ways that keep the menu feeling dynamic and inviting. Service at Handmade complements the food perfectly-attentive without being intrusive, staff members are genuinely knowledgeable about the menu and quick to offer suggestions, which makes exploring new dishes a real treat. Reviews from local diners frequently praise the consistency of both the food and the service, noting that the experience feels personal, like the team remembers returning guests and caters to their preferences. The location itself is convenient yet tucked enough to avoid the hustle of busier streets, making it an ideal stop for both casual lunches and evening outings. Whether you’re in the mood for something hearty or light, Handmade’s carefully curated menu and approachable atmosphere create an experience that keeps people coming back, blending quality, flavor, and charm seamlessly into one satisfying dining destination.

Most Popular Dishes

  • Cranberry Vanilla $
  • Apple Cider Soda $
  • Lavender Haze Kombucha $7.00
  • Iced London Fog $5.25
  • Blueberry Pomegrante Iced Tea $4.50
  • Vanilla Cold Brew + Heavy Cream $6.00
  • Cane Sugar Latte $6.25
  • Peppermint Tea $

Open Times

Monday 07:00 AM - 08:00 PM

Tuesday 07:00 AM - 08:00 PM

Wednesday 07:00 AM - 08:00 PM

Thursday 07:00 AM - 08:00 PM

Friday 07:00 AM - 09:00 PM

Saturday 08:00 AM - 09:00 PM

Sunday 08:00 AM - 08:00 PM

Icon

Location & Contact

Contact Details

  • 732 W New Orleans St, Broken Arrow, OK 74011, United States
  • Right Now :

What People's Say About Place

I went to this coffee shop for the first time the is week and it was absolutely amazing! First off there was this cute little note on the door! The decor & atmosphere was warm, clean and welcoming and made me feel right at home The staff were nice, coffee was amazing (tried somethig new) and they even have a play area for children. When I am back in the area I definitely want to go back If you’re looking for a place to get some work done, catch up with friends, or just get out of the house with your kids this would be the perfect coffee shop for you!

I really like this bakery! I’m always looking for a place that offers more healthy options. We got an array of items as I wanted to test them out. The apple pastry was so good! Flaky and tasty! The pumpkin bread, also delicious! Avocado toast = flavorful Lastly the iced coffee, my husband’s was better than mine, but that’s just not good ordering on my part. The iced caramel lattes are good so that’s a suggestion if you are unsure what to get. They also have some amazing locally crafted foods that are so worth the try! I grabbed a bag of basically spicy snack crackers and it hit my crave for spicy and it was balanced well with seasoning overall.

My husband is in a wheelchair and this place has plenty of room for him to get around. He was able to get up close to the food cases to see what he wanted.

Love this place! I haven't tried much, but my husband and I have been enjoying getting our date night dessert here. They have so much more though. Local items. Milk from Swans dairy too! The best! The staff have always been top tier friendly and professional. Always helpful and good conversation.

This is my go to coffee shop!! The atmosphere is cozy and bright, and the employees are always on their game They’re food, pastries and drinks are ALL delicious!!! Perfect place to hangout and read your Bible!!

Oh my! Handmade is so much more than what the name of the store says. But, I was more than pleasantly pleased! Walking in I came to see the Handmade items. But, I was surprised to see a coffee bar with things to eat. Seating was spacious and comfortable. All around the store there were homemade items ranging from soaps, to pickles, to sauces, to earrings and so much more. They even had a children's play area and room for parents to relax while watching their little ones. It felt very safe! I did order a pumpkin spice latte with oat milk. Mmmm good. The service was excellent too. The best thing I saw was that it was a good stream of people who came, stayed for a bit to listen to the easy music, or just ordered and left, like me. Oh, don't worry, I'll be back for sure!

Handmade is a nice little cafe with plenty of options for everyone. We primarily go for the coffee but have tried their pastries and paninis. Highly recommend all three options! Another nice point is that they have a children's play area. This lets the adults enjoy their coffee while the kids play. Lastly, they have a little market that is set up by local small business/vendors that's a cherry on top. Overall, it's a great little escape for local treats.

I got the chicken panini, very yummy ingredients and the bread was so good! However, without chips it was expensive just the sandwich by itself. As this was my first time at Handmade. The service was great and I love the atmosphere and that it’s child friendly.

Places Nearby